Friday, October 9, 2009

Lesson #1 EE - Modernism vs Postmodernism

Simple Characteristics of Modernism

1.) A value placed on science, reason, and Logic.
2.) This movement was believed to end misery, superstition and religion.
3.) Built on Objective truth.
4.) Some of the negative results of Modernism - The rationality of death camps, World War I and II, Hiroshima, and the advent of totalitarianism for many countries. Many of these ills were attributed to Enlightenment of Science and progress.
5.) Theological implications - An appeal to universally agreed truth. All truth is God's truth. This means that the use of Classic Apologetics became extremely prevalent. Many theologians also had an optimistic view of the world (Post and Amillennialism) were taught in the most prestigious religious institutions like Princeton.

The Shift to Post-Modernism

1.) After the death of Men like Hitler, Nietzsche, Mao, and Stalin the age of Reason was challenged and the void was filled with Post-Modernism.
2.) The loss of Reason brought loss of anything Sacred.
3.) There became a shift to Subjective truth.
4.) Based on Language and expressed in art.
5.) Theological implications - D.A. Carson wrote "The Gagging of God" which identifies the difficultly of communicating in a world with pluralism in science, culture and hermeneutics. This means that subjectivity gives every person a individual reference to reality which is independent on any objective or absolute.


Timeline of Modernism to PostModernism and the men who contributed to that shift.


Karl Barth c.1925 fideist approach to theology brought a rise in subjectivity
Martin Heidegger c.1927 rejected the philosophical grounding of the concepts of "subjectivity" and "objectivity"
Thomas Samuel Kuhn c.1962 posited the rapid change of the basis of scientific knowledge to a provisional consensus of scientists, coined the term "paradigm shift"
Jacques Derrida c.1967 re-examined the fundamentals of writing and its consequences on philosophy in general; sought to undermine the language of western metaphysics (deconstruction)
Michel Foucault c.1975 examined discursive power in Discipline and Punish, with Bentham's panopticon as his model, and also known for saying "language is oppression" (Meaning that language was developed to allow only those who spoke the language not to be oppressed. All other people that don't speak the language would then be oppressed.)
Jean-François Lyotard c.1979 opposed universality, meta-narratives, and generality
Richard Rorty c.1979 argues philosophy mistakenly imitates scientific methods; advocates dissolving traditional philosophical problems; anti-foundationalism and anti-essentialism
Jean Baudrillard c.1981 Simulacra and Simulation - reality disappears underneath the interchangeability of signs

Summary - The modern era brought forth science and reason, but lacked elements of compassion and empathy because of the stringent adherence to empirical evidence. Post-Modernism gave rise to spirituality, subjective beliefs and sensual expression. Postmoderns see arguments as propaganda, yet there is the ability to show others your position by living out what you believe.

No comments:

Post a Comment